Monday 18 February 1957

Won

Charlton
1–5
Man Utd

12′
Taylor
26′
Taylor
42′
Charlton
46′
Charlton
59′
Charlton
86′
Ayre
0′HTFT
  1. 12' Tommy Taylor
  2. 26' Tommy Taylor
  3. 42' Bobby Charlton
  4. 46' Bobby Charlton
  5. 59' Bobby Charlton
  6. 86' Bobby Ayre

Starting XI

11Pegg10Charlton×39Taylor×28Whelan7Berry
6McGuinness4Colman
3Bent5Jones2Byrne
1Wood

3-2-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.