Saturday 4 May 1957

Lost

Man Utd
1–2
Aston Villa

83′
Taylor
68′
McParland
73′
McParland
0′HTFT
  1. 68' Peter McParland
  2. 73' Peter McParland
  3. 83' Tommy Taylor

Starting XI

10Charlton11Pegg9Taylor7Berry8Whelan
6Edwards4Colman
3Byrne2Foulkes5Blanchflower
1Wood

3-2-5 — shape from recorded positions, not coordinates

Verified from 15 cited sources and the canonical match record.