Wednesday 2 October 1957

Won

Man Utd
3–2
Shamrock R

6′
Viollet
22′
Pegg
59′
Viollet
55′
McCann
68′
Hamilton
0′HTFT
  1. 6' Dennis Viollet
  2. 22' David Pegg
  3. 55' Maxie McCann
  4. 59' Dennis Viollet
  5. 68' Thomas Hamilton

Starting XI

11Pegg10Viollet×29Taylor8Webster7Berry
6McGuinness4Colman
3Byrne5Jones2Foulkes
1Wood

3-2-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 15 cited sources and the canonical match record.