Saturday 30 November 1957

Lost

Man Utd
3–4
Spurs

17′
Pegg
62′
Pegg
67′
Whelan
22′
Smith
25′
Smith
35′
Blanchflower (OG)
44′
Smith
0′HTFT
  1. 17' David Pegg
  2. 22' Bobby Smith
  3. 25' Bobby Smith
  4. 35' Jackie Blanchflower (own goal)
  5. 44' Bobby Smith
  6. 62' David Pegg
  7. 67' Billy Whelan

Starting XI

11Pegg×210Charlton9Webster8Whelan7Scanlon
6Edwards4Colman
3Byrne5Blanchflower2Foulkes
1Gaskell

3-2-5 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.