Wednesday 5 February 1958

Drawn

Red Star
3–3
Man Utd

2′
Viollet
30′
Charlton
31′
Charlton
46′
Kostic
50′
Tasic (P)
58′
Kostic
0′HTFT
  1. 2' Dennis Viollet
  2. 30' Bobby Charlton
  3. 31' Bobby Charlton
  4. 46' Bora Kostic
  5. 50' Lazar Tasic (penalty)
  6. 58' Bora Kostic

Starting XI

10Viollet9Taylor
11Scanlon8Charlton×24Colman7Morgans
3Byrne6Edwards5Jones2Foulkes
1Gregg

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 15 cited sources and the canonical match record.