Monday 31 March 1958

Lost

Aston Villa
3–2
Man Utd

13′
Webster
75′
Dawson
35′
Myerscough
65′
Hitchens
90′
Sewell
0′HTFT
  1. 13' Colin Webster
  2. 35' William Myerscough
  3. 65' Gerald Hitchens
  4. 75' Alex Dawson
  5. 90' John Sewell

Starting XI

10Charlton9Dawson
11Brennan8Pearson4Goodwin7Webster
3Cope6Crowther5Harrop2Foulkes
1Gregg

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.