Saturday 18 October 1958

Lost

Everton
32
Man Utd

72
82
19
Thomas
37
Thomas
55
Harris
0′HTFT
  1. 19' Eddie Thomas
  2. 37' Eddie Thomas
  3. 55' Jimmy Harris
  4. 72' Ronnie Cope
  5. 82' Ronnie Cope

Starting XI

4-4-2 approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.