Saturday 2 January 1960

Lost

Newcastle
7–3
Man Utd

27′
Dawson
61′
Quixall
80′
Quixall
7′
Hughes
16′
White
44′
White
54′
White
66′
Eastham (P)
76′
Bell
86′
Allchurch
0′HTFT
  1. 7' Gordon Hughes
  2. 16' Len White
  3. 27' Alex Dawson
  4. 44' Len White
  5. 54' Len White
  6. 61' Albert Quixall
  7. 66' George Eastham (penalty)
  8. 76' Jackie Bell
  9. 80' Albert Quixall
  10. 86' Ivor Allchurch

Starting XI

10Charlton9Viollet
11Scanlon8Quixall×24Goodwin7Dawson
3Carolan6Brennan5Cope2Foulkes
1Gaskell

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.