Wednesday 26 October 1960

Won

Man Utd
4–1
Exeter

7′
Quixall
25′
Giles
31′
Pearson
85′
Quixall
14′
Thompson (P)
0′HTFT
  1. 7' Albert Quixall
  2. 14' Jimmy Thompson (penalty)
  3. 25' Johnny Giles
  4. 31' Mark Pearson
  5. 85' Albert Quixall

Starting XI

10Pearson9Quixall×2
11Scanlon8Giles4Stiles7Dawson
3Carolan6Nicholson5Cope2Dunne
1Gaskell

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 15 cited sources and the canonical match record.