Saturday 17 December 1966

Won

West Brom
3–4
Man Utd

5′
Herd
13′
Herd
33′
Law
41′
Herd
8′
Astle
20′
Kaye
43′
Astle
0′HTFT
  1. 5' David Herd
  2. 8' Jeff Astle
  3. 13' David Herd
  4. 20' John Kaye
  5. 33' Denis Law
  6. 41' David Herd
  7. 43' Jeff Astle

Starting XI

10Herd×39Charlton
11Jr8Law4Crerand7Best
3Noble6Stiles5Sadler2Brennan
1Stepney

4-4-2 — approximate shape, inferred from classic shirt numbering

Verified from 20 cited sources and the canonical match record.